by Esme Addison

Politics and deception go together like peanut butter and jelly, but sometimes it’s less about the smooth spread and more about the sticky mess left behind. History is full of leaders who pulled off impressive feats of identity mischief, pretending to be something they’re not to gain power.

Whether it’s racial identity, religious background or nationality sometimes political parties will do shady things to get their candidate in office – or on the throne.

Here are five standout examples where political figures put on a show and, once in the spotlight, let their true colors shine.

1. Alexander the Great: The Divine Disguise

Let’s start with a man who knew how to make an entrance—Alexander the Great. Born to rule with a Macedonian pedigree, Alexander decided his legacy needed a divine twist. He portrayed himself as a god-king, claiming direct descent from Zeus to rally and control his vast empire.

Not exactly your average royal propaganda. While this godly image helped him unite diverse cultures under his rule, it wasn’t long before his actions diverged from his celestial persona. His adoption of Persian customs and the imposing proskynesis ritual (where subjects were expected to bow down to him) created more than a few grumbles among his Greek followers. Turns out, divine authority doesn’t always mix well with mortal discontent.

2. Elagabalus: The Religious Chameleon

Roman Emperor Elagabalus had a flair for drama that would make any soap opera proud. Initially, he leveraged his identity as a devout follower of the Eastern deity Elagabalus to gain power. This religious spin was part of his strategy to consolidate control over the Roman Empire.

However, once he ascended to power, his eccentric practices and radical religious reforms clashed with traditional Roman customs. Instead of a smooth transition, he faced mounting resistance. His reign became more of a religious soap opera than the stable leadership he promised, highlighting a grand disconnect between his presented piety and his actual governance.

The Okey-Doke: Five Times the US Government Bamboozled Black America

3. Rani Padmini: The Mythic Queen

Rani Padmini, the Rajput queen whose legend has outshone her reality, provides a colorful case of identity manipulation. Her story, although shrouded in myth, was used to galvanize Rajput resistance against invaders. She was portrayed as the ultimate symbol of valor and resistance, a beacon for regional pride.

However, the line between myth and reality blurred as her tale was used strategically for political ends. While the true details of her life remain debated, the mythic identity she was given played a powerful role in rallying support and resistance, showing how legends can be harnessed for political gain.

4. The Baron de La Haye: The Noble Pretender

Enter the 18th-century French aristocrat who wasn’t quite what he seemed—the Baron de La Haye. This commoner fancied himself a noble and donned the Baronial title to secure social and political advantages. The deception was a classic case of identity theft with a twist.

While he didn’t wield substantial political power or enact policies, his fabricated nobility led to scandal and a fall from grace when the truth came out. The lesson here? Faking your way into high society can lead to more than just a tarnished reputation.

5. Catherine the Great: The German Empress Who Played Russian

Catherine the Great’s rise to power wasn’t exactly straightforward. Born as a German princess, she knew that fitting into the Russian royal scene required a bit of strategic identity crafting. Once she became Empress, she skillfully presented herself as a champion of Russian culture and orthodoxy.

However, her reign was marked by a series of Westernizing reforms that sometimes clashed with traditional Russian values. While she played the role of a Russian empress to perfection, her policies often revealed a different agenda—one that aimed at modernizing Russia along Enlightenment lines, which was not always warmly received by her subjects.

Tips for Spotting a Pretender

So, how do you spot when someone’s playing a role rather than living their truth? Here are a few tips to keep your radar sharp:

1. Check the Consistency: If their story doesn’t match up over time or if their actions consistently contradict their proclaimed values, they might be hiding something.
2. Look for the Agenda: Often, those who present a manufactured identity have an agenda. Understand what’s at stake for them—power, money, or influence.
3. Scrutinize Their Allies: Who supports them? Sometimes, allies are as telling as the leader’s own actions. Are they backing someone who doesn’t quite fit the narrative?
4. Research Their Past: A little digging into their background can reveal inconsistencies. If their past doesn’t align with their present claims, it’s worth questioning.
5. Watch for Red Flags: Excessive grandstanding, sudden shifts in policy, or dramatic displays can be signs that someone is trying too hard to maintain a facade.

In the world of politics and power, appearances can be deceiving. Whether it’s Alexander the Great’s divine pretense or Catherine the Great’s strategic identity shift, history shows us that leaders have long been adept at playing roles. The key is to stay sharp, question the narratives, and remember that not everything is as it seems.

About The Author